GameStock
I wrote this as part of my latest newsletter but I wanted to share it as a blog post too, in case anyone finds it interesting. If reading it makes you interested in getting my newsletter you can sign up here.
I've been reading a lot recently about the GameStop shit storm. And while I don't know a huge amount about how stock markets work, I don't even know if there is one market and several exchanges or if they're different markets that are interconnected and so effectively the same market. Like the internet and a shopping centre. But I do know more than I used to and, perhaps most worryingly, I'm pretty sure I know more than a lot of people that have started playing the market over the past year. If you've not been looking, here's a rough timeline as far as I understand it (almost certainly full of flaws, do you own research):
The Robinhood app launched in 2015, it makes it dead easy for laymans and idiots and people that don't understand the stock market to play in it with small amounts of money. It gets a bunch of criticism for gamifying the experience of trading stocks (it sometimes gives you a burst of confetti when you make money), the company say it's just clear modern design (the interface goes green when you're making money, red when you're losing, totally nothing like a game).
For obvious reasons, in the last year more and more people have started fucking about with the app. There has been a lot of criticism from Wall Street types about how the app and others like it encourage people to gamble on the riskiest stocks, trading quickly to make a lot of small gains, but being too inexperienced to realise how much they're actually risking. The apps have been described as addictive by some, and there are certainly stories about people that have been using them compulsively.
GameStop is a chain of computer game shops and a website. They've been totally tanking over the past few years and their stock price is fucked. This meant that a bunch of hedge funds were short selling GameStop stock. The way I've seen this explained always uses cute examples and metaphors to make it seem like a personal thing, so I'm going to try and explain how I think it works. A person with a Scrooge McDuck style vault of money gives a large chunk of their money to a hedge fund. The hedge fund look at the market and see a company starting to fail, their stock price is dropping and it's probably going to keep tanking. So the hedge fund borrow some shares from a large company, probably another hedge fund, maybe one that's also invested by the same person with that McDuckian vault. And again the examples I've seen before use figures like £100 or £1000, I'm assuming it's more like millions. The first hedge fund takes the £1,000,000 of borrowed shares and sells them, banking the £1,000,000 (or more likely using it to turn other tricks and deals but that's beside the point and muddies the narrative I'm trying to build) and waiting for the stock to drop, at which point they buy it back for as little as possible, return the borrowed stock and pocket the difference. It sounds shady as fuck, but essentially it's just betting a stock will drop, in the same way that buying low and selling high is betting that it will rise. I don't think it's any different from an ethical point of view. (If you know anything about my politics you might be surprised to read that, well, wait for it.)
In late last year, maybe September, a fella who's name I forget (OK, fine, I looked it up, his name's Ryan Cohen and it was September) bought a 10% stake in GameStop becoming their largest individual shareholder. He blabbed a load about how he wanted to turn GameStop into a service to rival Amazon and GametStop share prices started rising again. No problem for the hedge funds, it's probably a blip, sit tight, wait for the stock to drop again and cash in.
With a lot of novices playing with stocks, they're going to want to find some advice, and a lot of them are American millennials so they turned to Reddit. The relevant group is called WallStBets and at some point one user noticed something interesting, the number of shares that had been short sold on the market accounted for more that 100% of the Gamestop shares. In other words, hedge fund One borrows from hedge fund Two, and then sells to hedge fund Three, and while they're all waiting for the stock price to bottom out hedge fund Three is sitting with a bunch of shares, so they loan them to hedge fund Four, who sells them to hedge fund Five, etc. etc. I don't know if there's some sort of limit on this (because I don't know enough about markets). Reddit being full of Reddit users it wasn't long before a plan was suggested and acted on to fuck with the short sellers, if enough people buy GameStop stock, it pushes up the price so the shares are worth more than hedge fund One got for them. But since they're borrowed they have no choice but to by them back at a loss. This is exactly what happened to one hedge fund called Melvin Capital. They lost 53% of it's value and had to be bailed out. So success, right? The little guy won!
Except, I think the little guy might be playing a different game. There was a fair amount of screaming and shouting at Robinhood in the middle of all this for restricting trading (and seemingly protecting the rich) and attempting to manipulate the market. They had a defence I don't have the knowledge to really judge, but what I find more interesting is how they make their money. One of the things that made them so successful is that they don't charge users a fee for doing trades, like most stock brokers. You might think this means they pay some other company to do it, but it's cleverer than that, they actually get paid for letting someone else make the actual trade. These companies are called Market Makers and the one that gets most of Robinhood's trades is Citadel Securities LLC. The Market Makers effectively (or maybe technically? I really don't know) trade the stock twice, skimming a fraction off the top as it passes though their books, so the more transactions, the more money they make. I mean, they're facilitating things, right? Isn't it fair for them to make money from providing a service? Sure. But here's the bit I've not really seen any headlines about, when Melvin Capital shat the bed they were bailed out by two companies, $750,000,000 from Point72 (run by a guy who's old firm plead guilty to insider trading) and $2,000,000,000 from Citadel LLC, who, you may or may not be surprised to learn are the parent company for Citadel Securities LLC that I just mentioned making all that money just a few sentences ago. While some of the Redditers are celebrating sticking it to the elites I can't help imaging someone in a country club winding up a friend because their investment company had to bail out the friend's hedge fund. Not to mention the other hedge funds that still own GameStop shares and are big enough to just sit and have a pint until this whole thing blows over.
For me, part of the problem (I'm almost done, promise) is how people think about the stock market and specifically the ethics around it. Buying stock is always described as investing. It gives the impression, which I think most people believe without really thinking about it, that when you buy stocks, the company in question gets at least some of the money, after fees and whatnot. This is only the case if you're buying shares directly from the company when they first float the ownership on the market, or they create more shares. More often you're just buying them from another trader and the company isn't involved or affected. Like buying a mint condition 1970s Millennium Falcon on eBay, Lucasarts doesn't get any money. But that doesn't matter, because it feels like we're investing in a company. We're hoping they'll do well, and we're putting our money on the line to help that happen, hoping things and people do well is positive, helping is positive, all this is positive and therefore must be ethically and morally good and right, right? By extension short selling is bad. It's hoping someone does badly, it's mean and ethically and morally wrong. Disney and He-man always told me so. But the reality is it's all gambling and neither is more right or wrong than the other.
In conclusion, the only real winner is capitalism and the people at the top of the machine. There's currently a lot of shouting about investigations into how this happened, Robinhood restricting trading etc. etc. and I'm sure changes to the market will be enforced, but I think it's naive to think those changes will have anything to do with short selling, or any practice the public think of as bad or mean. And it arguably shouldn't, lots of clever economists believe short selling is necessary for the market to work the way it should, stopping bubbles around over hyped stock from getting too out of control. What I think will change is the ability for a crowd of Reddit users to openly and intentionally influence the market to such an enormous scale.
To get extremist for a moment, to me the stock market is inherently unethical. The price of a share isn't based on what a company's actual monetary value is at that moment, it's what someone else will pay for it, the potential of how valuable that share could become. A company being able to sell shares of ownership allows them to get money and do better business, but the market is a completely separate entity that doesn't care which companies succeed or fail, as long as they keep trading. And while it doesn't matter which companies do what, it is necessary for some of them to fail so the system can keep functioning. There must always be change, so that there is always trade. Like a casino it's a system that's designed to funnel money to the house while the players feel like they're winning.
I could and probably should be better at naming sources and stuff but I'm too lazy and this is a rant not a dissertation. Most of the information came from these:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GameStop_short_squeeze
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/08/technology/robinhood-risky-trading.html
https://www.vox.com/recode/22254270/robinhood-gamestop-amc-block-wallstreetbets-day-trading
https://marketsweekly.ghost.io/what-happened-with-gamestop/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_Cohen
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/melvin-announces-2-75-billion-investment-from-citadel-and-point72--301214477.html#:~:text=25%2C%202021%20%2FPRNewswire%2F%20%2D%2D,Founder%20and%20CEO%20Gabriel%20Plotkin.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-retail-trading-melvin-idUSKBN2A00KW